What Was Marcus Aurelius Grateful For? The Thank-You List in Meditations Book 1
Short answer: Marcus Aurelius opened his Meditations with a full book of thanks. In Book 1 he names his grandfather, mother, teachers, brother and adoptive father, and writes down exactly what each taught him, such as being "gentle and meek" (1.1) or "always to hope the best" (1.14). He thanked people for character rather than possessions, and in 7.27 he advised valuing what is present without clinging to it.
With Thanksgiving on Thursday, November 26, 2026 (the fourth Thursday in November under 5 U.S.C. § 6103), many people will be asked to name what they are thankful for, often with a minute's notice and a table full of listeners. Marcus Aurelius faced that question in private and answered it at length. The first book of his Meditations is, in effect, one long thank-you list. It is also the most practical model of gratitude in the whole Stoic tradition, because it does not stop at feeling thankful. It says exactly what each person gave him.
Book 1: a notebook that begins with debts
Most books open with an argument. The Meditations opens with names. Before a single Stoic doctrine appears, Marcus goes through the people who shaped him, one by one, and writes down what he learned from each. The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy (substantive revision March 31, 2025) notes that in Book I "he records his gratitude to his Stoic teachers Rusticus, Apollonius, Sextus for their examples and teachings."
All quotes below are from the public-domain translation by Meric Casaubon (1634), free on Project Gutenberg. That edition groups the passages differently from modern ones, so we give the modern book.section number for each.
He begins at home. "Of my grandfather Verus I have learned to be gentle and meek, and to refrain from all anger and passion" (1.1). From his mother, "to be religious, and bountiful; and to forbear, not only to do, but to intend any evil" (1.3).
Then come his teachers. To Rusticus he is "beholding, that I first entered into the conceit that my life wanted some redress and cure," and grateful that through him "I lighted upon Epictetus" (1.7). From Apollonius he took the ideal of being "still the same man" whether "in the sharpest pains, or after the loss of a child, or in long diseases" (1.8).
Some entries are small and very human. From Alexander the Platonic he learned not to say or write to anyone "'I am not at leisure'" as an excuse for neglecting friends (1.12). From his brother Severus, "always to hope the best; and to be confident that my friends love me" (1.14).
The longest entry is a portrait of his adoptive father, the emperor Antoninus Pius: "his readiness to hear any man, that had aught to say tending to any common good," "His contented mind in all things, his cheerful countenance" (1.16). The book closes by thanking the gods for "good grandfathers, and parents, a good sister, good masters, good domestics, loving kinsmen, almost all that I have" (1.17).
What makes this gratitude Stoic
Three features set Book 1 apart from a generic list of blessings.
- It thanks people for character, not things. Marcus was an emperor with everything money could buy, yet almost nothing in Book 1 is a possession. He is grateful for patience, plain speech, steadiness and kindness, the things Stoics held to be truly good.
- It is specific. He does not write "thankful for my teachers." He writes what Rusticus taught, what Sextus modelled, what Alexander corrected. Specific thanks are harder to fake and easier to act on.
- It turns into practice. Each entry doubles as a standard he holds himself to. Thanking his grandfather for being "gentle and meek" is also a reminder to be gentle himself.
He even includes a note about how to receive kindness. From Apollonius he learned to accept favours from friends without becoming beholden to them, "and yet so that I should not pass them neither, as an unsensible and unthankful man" (1.8).
Gratitude for what is present, without clinging
Marcus returns to gratitude later in a passage modern editions number 7.27. He tells himself not to dwell on things he lacks, but "of those that are present, take some aside, that thou takest most benefit of, and consider of them particularly, how wonderfully thou wouldst want them, if they were not present."
Then comes a Stoic caution: "take heed withal, lest that whilst thou dost settle thy contentment in things present, thou grow in time so to overprize them, as that the want of them (whensoever it shall so fall out) should be a trouble and a vexation unto thee." (Gutenberg prints "dust" for "dost" here; we have corrected the obvious misprint.)
That balance is the heart of it. Appreciate what you have as if you might lose it, because you might, but do not build your peace on keeping it. Even in his list of thanks to the gods, Marcus notes "that it being so that my mother was to die young, yet she lived with me all her latter years" (1.17). Gratitude and loss sit in the same sentence.
A five-step Book 1 practice for Thanksgiving week
You do not need to write a book. You can write a page in the ten days before November 26.
- Choose five people. One from family, one teacher or mentor, one friend, one person you have never thanked, and one you found difficult. Marcus included Rusticus, with whom he admits he was "often displeased" (1.17).
- Use his sentence shape. Write "From ___, I learned ___." Name a trait or habit, not a gift.
- Add one concrete memory. Marcus remembered a single letter Rusticus wrote to his mother "from Sinuessa" (1.7). A detail makes the thanks real.
- Turn it into a standard. Under each line, write one way you will practise that trait this week.
- Tell one of them. Marcus wrote for himself, but his own rule from Alexander applies: do not put off what you owe your friends. A short message or a word at the table is enough.
If you are asked at Thursday's meal what you are thankful for, you will have an answer that is honest and specific, and one that honours a person rather than a possession.
What this is not
Stoic gratitude is not forced cheerfulness, and it does not mean pretending hard things are good. Marcus wrote Book 1 while carrying grief, illness and the weight of a war. If the holidays bring loneliness, grief or low mood that feels heavy or constant, it is worth talking with someone you trust or a licensed professional. Reading the Stoics can be a companion to that support, not a substitute for it.
Continue the conversation
To take this further, the Aurelius Meditations app lets you talk through your own list with an AI modelled on Marcus Aurelius, Epictetus and Seneca. It is an AI, not the historical philosopher, and its replies are for reflection, not professional advice. For more from this blog, read Marcus on caring what others think (12.4), on dealing with anger (11.18), and on getting out of bed (5.1). If the season holds a loss for you, the Remember Me blog has gentle ideas for keeping memories close.
FAQ
Where does Marcus Aurelius write about gratitude?
Mostly in Book 1 of the Meditations, which lists what he learned from family, teachers and friends and ends with thanks to the gods (1.17). Passage 7.27 adds advice on appreciating what is present without clinging to it.
Who did Marcus Aurelius thank in Book 1?
His grandfather Verus, his father and mother, his great-grandfather, teachers including Diognetus, Rusticus, Apollonius, Sextus and Fronto, his brother Severus, Claudius Maximus, his adoptive father Antoninus Pius, and finally the gods.
How can I practise Stoic gratitude?
Copy the shape of Book 1: write "From ___, I learned ___" for a few people, name a trait rather than a gift, add one concrete memory, and turn each line into a habit you will practise. Then thank at least one of them directly.
Which translation are these quotes from?
Meric Casaubon's 1634 English translation, in the public domain and free on Project Gutenberg as eBook #2680. Its section numbers differ from modern editions, so this post gives modern book.section numbers.
Sources
- Marcus Aurelius, Meditations 1.1, 1.3, 1.7, 1.8, 1.12, 1.14, 1.16, 1.17 and 7.27 (Book 1 sections I, IV, V, IX, XI, XIII, XIV and Book 7 section XX in this edition), tr. Meric Casaubon (1634), Project Gutenberg eBook #2680 (accessed/as of 2026-11-16)
- Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, "Marcus Aurelius" (substantive revision Mar 31, 2025) (accessed/as of 2025-03-31)
- 5 U.S.C. § 6103 (Thanksgiving Day, the fourth Thursday in November), Cornell LII (accessed/as of 2026-11-16)
Get Aurelius Meditations on the App Store