Aurelius Meditations

What Did Marcus Aurelius Say About Caring What Others Think? (Meditations 12.4)

Short answer: Marcus Aurelius thought it strange that we each love ourselves most, yet trust other people's opinion of us more than our own. In Meditations 12.4 he wrote that "we fear more what our neighbours will think of us, than what we ourselves." His answer was not to stop caring about people but to stop living for their verdict: spend your attention on whether your own actions are "just and holy" (4.18), and remember that praise makes nothing better or worse (4.20).

Few worries are as old as this one. An emperor of Rome, a man whose every word was recorded and judged, still caught himself wondering what others would say. The Meditations, the private notebook Marcus Aurelius kept in the 170s, return to the question again and again. He never wrote a treatise on reputation. He wrote short reminders to himself, and read together they make a clear and usable method.

The passage people mean: Meditations 12.4

The line most often quoted on this subject comes from Book 12. In the public-domain translation by Meric Casaubon (1634), free on Project Gutenberg, it appears as section III of the Twelfth Book, because older editions number the entries differently. Modern editions call it 12.4. It reads:

"I have often wondered how it should come to pass, that every man loving himself best, should more regard other men's opinions concerning himself than his own."

He then offers a small thought experiment. If a god or "grave master" stood beside us and commanded us "to think nothing by himself but what he should presently speak out" no one "were able to endure it, though but for one day." His conclusion: "Thus do we fear more what our neighbours will think of us, than what we ourselves."

The point is sharp. We would be ashamed to have our private thoughts heard aloud, which means we already know our own minds are where the real work lies. Yet we spend our worry on the opinions of others, which we cannot see and do not control.

Four reminders from the Meditations, step by step

Marcus does not tell himself to become cold or indifferent to people. Elsewhere he insists we are "made for society." What he trains is where his attention goes. Here are four passages, quoted from the Casaubon translation, in the order you might use them.

  1. Notice the imbalance (12.4). When you catch yourself replaying what someone might think, name it the way Marcus did: you are giving their imagined opinion more weight than your own honest judgment of what you did.
  2. Stop spending your days on other people's minds (3.4). "Spend not the remnant of thy days in thoughts and fancies concerning other men, when it is not in relation to some common good." He lists exactly what to drop: "what such a man doth, and to what end: what he saith, and what he thinks." Notice the exception. Thinking about others for a shared good is fine. Guessing at their verdict on you is not.
  3. Look at your own work instead (4.18). "Now much time and leisure doth he gain, who is not curious to know what his neighbour hath said, or hath done, or hath attempted, but only what he doth himself, that it may be just and holy?" In Casaubon this is section XV of Book 4, and the opening "Now" is almost certainly a misprint for "How." The question shifts from "How will this look?" to "Is this right?"
  4. Remember that praise adds nothing (4.20). "That which is fair and goodly, whatsoever it be... is so of itself, and terminates in itself, not admitting praise as a part or member: that therefore which is praised, is not thereby made either better or worse." A kind act is just as kind if no one sees it. A careless one is no better for being applauded.

Why this feels harder now

Marcus worried about his neighbours. Today the neighbourhood is enormous. Pew Research Center's report on social media use, published November 20, 2025, found that 84% of U.S. adults say they ever use YouTube and 71% use Facebook, and that about half visit each of those platforms at least once a day, including 37% who visit Facebook several times a day (Pew Research Center, Nov. 20, 2025). Each visit is a small chance to wonder how we are being seen.

The calendar adds to it this month. Thanksgiving falls on Thursday, November 26, 2026, the fourth Thursday in November under federal law (5 U.S.C. § 6103, Cornell LII), and the season of family tables, year-end reviews and holiday photos follows close behind. These are the very settings where the fear Marcus describes in 12.4 tends to show up.

A five-minute practice for the evening

This is a simple way to put the four reminders to work. It draws only on the passages above.

  1. Write down one opinion you worried about today. Keep it to one line: "I think my manager thought my update was weak."
  2. Ask the 12.4 question. What is my own honest judgment of what I did? Write that line too.
  3. Apply the 3.4 test. Does thinking about their view serve some shared good, such as fixing a real mistake or repairing a relationship? If yes, write the one action it calls for. If no, set it down.
  4. Ask the 4.18 question. Was what I did just and honest? That is the only verdict you fully control.
  5. Close with 4.20. Read the line "that therefore which is praised, is not thereby made either better or worse" once, slowly, and let the day end there.

The goal is not to become someone who never cares. It is to become someone whose own conscience gets the first and final word.

What this is not

Marcus is not advising you to ignore feedback. In 3.4 he carves out thoughts that serve "some common good," and honest criticism you can learn from belongs there. He is also not describing a mood you can switch on. These are reminders he wrote to himself because he needed them repeatedly. If worry about others' opinions is constant or overwhelming, it is worth talking with someone you trust or a licensed professional. Stoic reading is a companion to that support, not a substitute for it.

Continue the conversation

If you want to take these passages further, the Aurelius Meditations app lets you ask an AI modelled on Marcus Aurelius, Epictetus and Seneca about a situation in your own words. It is an AI, not the historical philosopher, and its replies are for reflection, not professional advice. For more from this blog, read Marcus on dealing with anger (Meditations 11.18) and on getting out of bed in the morning (Meditations 5.1).

FAQ

Where does Marcus Aurelius talk about caring what others think?

The best-known passage is Meditations 12.4, where he wonders why every man, loving himself best, should more regard other men's opinions of himself than his own. Related reminders appear in 3.4, 4.18 and 4.20. In the Casaubon translation on Project Gutenberg, 12.4 appears as section III of Book 12 because of older numbering.

Did Marcus Aurelius say to stop caring about other people?

No. He told himself to stop spending his days on thoughts about other men unless it served some common good. Caring for people and learning from honest criticism still count. What he dropped was living for their verdict.

What is the Stoic test for whether an opinion matters?

Marcus shifts the question from how something looks to whether it is right. In 4.18 he praises the person who asks only whether what he does himself is just and holy, and in 4.20 he notes that what is praised is not made better or worse by the praise.

Which translation are these quotes from?

All quotes are from Meric Casaubon's 1634 English translation of the Meditations, which is in the public domain and free on Project Gutenberg as eBook #2680.

Sources

  1. Marcus Aurelius, Meditations 12.4, 3.4, 4.18 and 4.20 (sections XII.III, III.IV, IV.XV and IV.XVI in this edition), tr. Meric Casaubon (1634), Project Gutenberg eBook #2680 (accessed/as of 2026-11-14)
  2. Pew Research Center, "Americans' Social Media Use 2025" (surveys of 5,022 and 5,123 U.S. adults, Feb.-June 2025) (accessed/as of 2025-11-20)
  3. 5 U.S.C. § 6103 (Thanksgiving Day, the fourth Thursday in November), Cornell LII (accessed/as of 2026-11-14)